All our cookies are fresh-from-the-oven and made in our Amish Country kitchen! Generously sized and packed full of the finest ingredients, our cookies are sure to please.
Prices listed are per dozen.
Possible substitutions during warm weather months on all products with chocolate.
Due to our dough mixing process, all of our products may have come in contact with nut oils.
|Buttermilk SugarOne of our most popular cookies, these soft buttermilk cookies are baked then sprinkled with... [more]|
|CoconutEven the most discriminating taste will enjoy our soft buttery coconut cookies!|
|Oatmeal RaisinThese tender, moist Amish treats will take you back to a simpler time. Soft and chewy, our... [more]|
|Peanut ButterEveryone loves peanut butter and these crispy on the edges, chewy in the center cookies are... [more]|
|SnickerdoodlesThis shortbread cookie with a funny name is rolled in a tasty cinnamon-sugar mixture then baked to... [more]|
|MacaroonsThese soft moist baked coconut treats are so delectable, they may remind you of a favorite candy... [more]|